Back to blog

Le Corbusier’s love of the ocean liner

See blog

Readers' comments

Reader comments are listed below. Comments are currently closed and new comments are no longer being accepted.

Sort:

rusholmeruffian

The ocean liner is self-contained by necessity. By contrast, there is no reason for an urban housing development to be self-contained...unless you want to keep its inhabitants isolated, which seems to have been the goal for a great deal of social housing on both sides of the Atlantic.

There is no need for urban housing to be self contained, that is true. But if it is self-contained, you have shorter distances and better efficiency. If the super market and other facilities are within 3 minutes waking distance, that is definitely a plus. An interesting project in this respect is the Olympic Village in Munich, Germany. It is pretty self-contained (if you need complicated brain surgery, you need to go downtown) and appears to "work", i.e to be unproblematic in view of the social problems mentioned in the article.