Back to blog

Why Indians love sports films

See blog

Readers' comments

Reader comments are listed below. Comments are currently closed and new comments are no longer being accepted.


Tropicana312 in reply to guest-naialwm

You sound like the Mathematics dud, who defends the underperformance with 90% in ...wait...Geography !!
In the larger scheme of the World, Cricket is a non sport with 90% of enthusiasts from South Asia - with other countries being equal noobs when it comes to Sports.

It seems so easy sitting on the other side. But it is stupid to think Indians don't make rational decisions when it comes to sports! :)

I won 2 Gold medals in Judo and represented my state when I was in high-school. I also had a bronze in Maths olympiad. Post schooling, the choices were easy. Study for IIT JEE and become an engineer or go full time with the training academy and make Judo as a professional career. The former, it seemed then, led to somewhat steady income. The latter choice had a "school-Judo-teacher" written all over it. Or at least, it seemed that way.

Now in US, with a PhD from Carnegie Mellon, I wonder if that was a right choice. Perhaps, it was! Perhaps, it was not. But I guess most Indians make the same choice when it comes to sports. Europeans or Americans perhaps, don't have to make the same choice. There is an offer from university waiting for you. Not in India, where 800,000 compete for 5,000 spots (actually 500 spots, if you are particular about a stream, and 25 spots if you want a particular college).

Cricket is a aberration, because now there is an easier path to stardom and financial security, or may be it seems from outside :)

guest-naialwm in reply to TS2912

Yes, Cricket is a sport. So is Kabaddi. And Indians are good at them :)
Lol. You want the average Indian to compete in shooting that requires a specialized 5,000$ gun, or 600$ suite with a 500,000$ swimming pool, or a 500,000$ astro turf, or that 200,000$ a year coach. Dude, get over it.
The only thing surprising is why Indians don't play football. Olympics sports need a money pit and are not for an average joe!


The author seems to conflate Bollywood with the entire Indian film industry. Bollywood is watched by 40 percent of the Indians. Regional cinema like the Malayalam film industry makes a lot more noir style movies. This kind of unidimensional view of any subject is getting to be more common in western media, and among its audiences.

I have to hear statements like "Shakespeare is the greatest playwright in history" from people who can't name a poet or author in an Asian or African language.


"Why Indians love sports films"

Probably because, going by a lifetime of abysmal performance in the Olympics, Indians are terrible at real-life sports.


It's a (fictionalized) biopic about an actual family who won actual medals in an actual competition. I'm sorry you are being spoiled by the historical record of the 2010 Commonwealth Games.


Everyone loves a winner, specially when the victory comes after a real fight. And there is nothing new to it. How could you forget:

Rocky (1976)
Rocky II (1979)
Rocky III (1982)
Rocky IV (1985)
Rocky V (1990)
Rocky Balboa (2006)
Creed (2015)
Creed II (2017)

Sir Alex is gone long live Sir Alex

India does underperform horribly relative to population. you would think that sheer weight of numbers would be enough to see them have medalists here or there. A single silver and bronze last year tells the story.


A sad footnote on a civilization that hasn't promoted sports. It's not even taught in the family. A recipe for disaster. Your going to get some really unhealthy people. I guess they need to migrate to the West, to understand the importance of incorporating sports in addition to an emphasis on education. Too much visceral fat in Indians, and obiesity in the educated, richer ones, combined with the highest diabetes percentages in the world, make Indians in desperate need for some good sports education. It's not going to happen, and bad eating habits, and sedentary lifestyles, among the educated and rich are going to hurt India.

SealTeamSix in reply to Tropicana312

Well, cricket world cups have the highest coverage after Olympics and World Cup football.

As for the 90 percent figure, let's accept that 75 percent of civilized world history took place in Asia. the Indian sub continent had 30 percent of world history from 2800 B.C. to 1800 A.D.


Prospero's correctly identifies some of the reasons these sports movies do well in India. But it's not really the whole story. Sports-based movies do well even in the US, which has lots of real-life, contemporary sporting glories to its name.

End of the day, movies like Dangal do well because they are well made and entertaining. While a movie that wasn't entertaining wouldn't do well, no matter how nostaliga-inducing it was.

And while romance does remain Bollywoods biggest genre, its thankfully diversifying fast. Besides sports-movies, there are genres like Satire, Mystery, Crime, buddy /road-trip movies, political thrillers, historical dramas, biopics, court-room dramas etc. that don't revolve around romance. (Neerja is a great example of a non-romance Bollywood blockbuster; Peepli Live & Jolly LLB as examples of Satire).


The writer reveals the films ending in the first sentence. That's a degree of stupid you don't see often. Really. I'm gobsmacked.